Chicago Style Deep Dish Pizza

My college roommate from Chicago spent three weeks trying to convince me that real pizza needed a knife and fork. I thought he was crazy until that first bite of buttery crust piled high with cheese and sauce. Now I understand why people get passionate about this. The dough becomes something closer to cornbread than traditional pizza crust, and the whole experience feels like eating a savory pie.

We made six of these pizzas during Super Bowl weekend one year. My brotherinlaw stood over the oven watching the cheese brown through the glass door like it was the most important game on television. Nobody spoke when we finally pulled them out. Just the sound of forks hitting plates and someone asking if there was more.

Ingredients

• Allpurpose flour and cornmeal: The cornmeal gives the crust that distinct texture and subtle sweetness that makes deep dish so recognizable
• Active dry yeast: Make sure your water feels like bath temperature any hotter and youll kill the yeast before it can work
• Olive oil and melted butter: This fat combination is what creates that incredibly rich golden crust that almost fries itself as it bakes
• Mozzarella and Parmesan: The mozzarella melts into that signature stretch while Parmesan adds a salty sharpness that cuts through the richness
• Crushed tomatoes: Dont use pureed tomatoes here you want those tomato chunks and texture on top
• Your chosen toppings: Layer them directly on the cheese first then sauce on top this is the backwards magic of deep dish

Instructions

Wake up the yeast:

Stir the yeast into warm water and watch for that foam layer to form. This takes about five minutes and tells you the yeast is alive and ready to work. If nothing happens start over with new yeast.

Mix and knead the dough:

Combine everything in a large bowl and knead until smooth. The dough should feel soft and slightly tacky but not sticky. Let it rise in a warm spot until doubled about an hour.

Simmer the sauce:

Cook the garlic in olive oil just until fragrant. Add the crushed tomatoes with herbs and let it bubble away for twenty minutes. The sauce should thicken slightly but stay chunky.

Build it upside down:

Press the dough into your deep dish pan and push it up the sides. Layer cheese first then toppings then sauce on top. This feels wrong but trust the process.

Bake until bubbly:

Bake at 425 degrees for thirtyfive to forty minutes. The crust should be deep golden and the sauce should be bubbling all the way to the center.

Save to Pinterest

This is what Friday nights were made for in my house. Something about the ritual of building it layer by layer then waiting those long minutes while it bakes. The smell fills the entire kitchen and somehow makes the week feel manageable again.

The Cheese Strategy

Ive learned to use more cheese than seems reasonable because it settles into the layers as it bakes. Fresh mozzarella cut into cubes creates amazing pockets of melted cheese throughout. But shredded works perfectly fine and is easier to distribute evenly across that thick crust.

Sauce Timing

Making the sauce ahead gives the flavors time to marry. I often make it the day before and keep it in the refrigerator. Room temperature sauce spreads more evenly over the toppings and wont cool down the cheese layer quite as much when you assemble the pizza.

Getting That Perfect Crust

The olive oil in the pan is nonnegotiable for that crispy edge. I use a pastry brush to coat every inch including up the sides. Some people even brush melted butter over the baked crust during the last five minutes for extra richness.

• Preheat your oven for at least twenty minutes before baking
• Check the pizza at thirty minutes and cover edges with foil if theyre browning too fast
• Let it cool longer than you think you need to that sauce holds heat like nothing else

Save to Pinterest

Cut thick wedges and serve with forks. This is pizza that demands your full attention and a little patience.

Common Questions

→ What makes Chicago-style deep dish different from regular pizza?

The key differences include the thick, buttery crust formed up the sides of a deep pan, the unique layering sequence with cheese and toppings placed directly on dough before sauce, and the longer baking time which creates a hearty, fork-required meal rather than a hand-held slice.

→ Why is the sauce placed on top of the cheese?

This traditional Chicago assembly method protects the cheese from burning during the extended bake time while allowing the sauce to develop rich flavor. The sauce also keeps the cheese from drying out, creating that signature gooey, molten texture throughout.

→ Can I make the dough ahead of time?

Absolutely. Prepare the dough through the rising step, then refrigerate it for up to 24 hours before bringing to room temperature and shaping. This actually enhances flavor development and can make the dough easier to work with.

→ What type of pan works best for deep dish pizza?

A traditional deep-dish pizza pan or cast-iron skillet works ideally, though a round cake pan at least 2 inches deep also produces excellent results. The key is having enough depth for the thick crust and generous toppings.

→ How long should I let the pizza rest before slicing?

Allowing 10 minutes of resting time is crucial for deep dish pizza. This lets the cheese set slightly and makes slicing much cleaner, plus it prevents the molten cheese from running out when you cut into those thick, hearty layers.

→ Can I freeze the assembled pizza before baking?

Yes, assemble the complete pizza in the pan, wrap tightly with plastic wrap and foil, then freeze for up to 1 month. Bake from frozen, adding 10-15 minutes to the baking time and covering edges with foil if needed.